Rohit vs Kohli Test Captaincy: Who is the best test captain at home?

After the recent loss of the first test match against England by 28 runs, many cricket fans started drawing a comparison of Rohit vs Kohli test captaincy at home ground and overseas. Indeed, it was the 7th test match for Rohit Sharma as a captain on Indian soil.

Both Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli possess diverse batting styles and have a different approach towards the game as a captain.

Especially, the transition in the captaincy for test cricket has been smoother in the last 10 years.

In late 2014, Virat Kohli took over the test captaincy from MS Dhoni and led Team India till 2022. However, he stepped down as the test captain and handed over the responsibility to Rohit Sharma.

Team India wasn’t able to clinch the ICC World Test Championship trophy under Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma’s captaincy in 2021 and 2023, despite entering into the finals with dominating wins against other teams.

Compared to Virat Kohli’s 8 years of captaincy, Rohit Sharma’s tenure as a test captain is shorter with only 2 years of experience.

Earlier, the Indian cricket team became a consistent side under Sourav Ganguly’s captaincy. But, it was under MS Dhoni’s leadership that Team India reached the top position in the ICC rankings of test cricket.

Ultimately, the team led by Virat Kohli played a fearless battle against the toughest opposition and became the best team in red-ball cricket. 

Rohit vs Kohli Test Captaincy: Records at Home Ground

Here is the detailed analysis of Rohit vs Kohli test captaincy at home ground provided with detailed information about the total number of test matches won and their success rate:

Virat Kohli test captaincy at Home:

Interestingly, Virat Kohli captained India in a majority of test matches. Also, he became the greatest test captain in cricket history by surpassing the previous records of MS Dhoni and Sourav Ganguly.

Rarely, Team India lost only two test matches against Australia and England under Virat Kohli’s captaincy at home ground.

Here is the captaincy record of Virat Kohli in 68 test matches played at home and overseas:

Homeground:

Total Matches PlayedNumber of Matches played at HomeWinLossDrawSuccess Rate at HomeOverall Success Rate
6831242577.41%58.82%

Overseas:

Total Matches Played at OverseasMatches won at OverseasMatches lost at homeDraw MatchSuccess Rate at Overseas
371615643.24%

Rohit Sharma test captaincy at Home:

Under Rohit Sharma’s captaincy, Team India lost a test match against England at home.

Here is the captaincy record of Rohit Sharma in test matches played at home and overseas:

Homeground:

Total Matches PlayedNumber of Matches played at HomeWinLossDrawSuccess Rate at HomeOverall Success Rate
12742157.14%58.33%

Overseas:

Total Matches Played at OverseasMatches won at OverseasMatches lost at homeDraw MatchSuccess Rate at Overseas
522140%

Rohit vs Kohli Test Captaincy: Series Wins at Home

Team India played 10 test series at home on Virat Kohli’s captaincy. On the other side, the ongoing test series against England is the 3rd one for Rohit Sharma.

Test Series Wins under Virat Kohli’s Captaincy at Homeground:

Virat Kohli’s first test match captaincy began against Australia in 2014 at Adelaide. Though India lost the game, Virat Kohli delivered an exceptional performance by scoring two back-to-back centuries in both innings.

Out of the 10 test match series at home, Team India won 9 under Virat Kohli’s captaincy, including a series leveled against Australia in 2017.

Here is the list of test match series Team India performed under Virat Kohli’s captaincy from 2015 to 2022 at Homeground:

S.NoSeriesNumber of test matches in the seriesSeries WinnerResult
1.South Africa tour of India 20154India3-0
2.New Zealand tour of India 2016 3India3-0
3.England Tour of India 20165India4-0
4.Bangladesh Tour of India 20171India1-0
5.Australia Tour of India 20173Leveled1-1
6.Sri Lanka Tour of India 20172India1-0
7.West Indies Tour of India 20182India2-0
8.South Africa Tour of India 20193India3-0
9.Bangladesh Tour of India 20192India2-0
10.England Tour of India 20214India3-1
11.New Zealand Tour of India 20212India1-0

Test Series Wins under Rohit Sharma’s captaincy at Home:

Rohit Sharma began his era as a test match captain on 4th March 2022 against Sri Lanka at PCA Stadium, Mohali. Under his captaincy, India won the first test match of the series by an innings and 222 runs.

Here is the list of series wins for Team India under Rohit Sharma’s captaincy at home from 2022 to till date (30th January 2024):

S.NoSeriesNumber of test matches in the seriesSeries WinnerResult
1.Sri Lanka Tour of India 20222India2-0
2.Australia Tour of India 20235India3-1
3.England Tour of India 20235Ongoing (To be Decided)1-0 (England)

Rohit vs Kohli Test Captaincy at Homeground: Conclusive Facts

Both Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli have fared well as a test captain at home. At this stage, it would be impossible to compare the captaincy record. It is because Rohit Sharma has less experience as a test captain compared to Virat Kohli.

Moreover, Virat Kohli has registered a majority of test wins as a captain at home after playing 31 matches. Whereas, Rohit Sharma has played only 7 test matches on the Indian ground.

However, it would be difficult to determine the best captain at home ground with equal performance in the competition of Rohit vs Kohli test captaincy.

Finally, it is to be seen if Rohit Sharma can win the ongoing 5-match test series against England, as the visiting side currently takes the lead with 1-0.